“A Carol for Two” Movie Review

We are rolling along in the Countdown to Christmas season and I’m loving all the Christmas movies. This movie has a huge list of Broadway talent in it and I’ve been so excited for it! Let’s dive into our “A Carol for Two” movie review!

Alex and Violette are about to hug after the end of their duet at the end of "A Carol For Two" movie.
Photo Courtesy of HallmarkChannel.com

I was SO excited for this movie when I saw it was on the list this year. Not one, not two, but MULTIPLE broadway stars in it? With singing? In New York City? At Christmas? SIGN ME UP. It’s bound to be wonderful. I can’t help but love the story of someone moving to the big city to chase their dreams either. Let’s dive right in and find out if it’s as awesome as I think it’ll be.

Jordan Litz and Ginna Claire Mason smile on the set of "A Carol for Two" movie
Photo Courtesy of HallmarkChannel.com

My Review

Above I was wondering if this movie could be as wonderful as I thought it could be based on just what I know going into it. And… spoiler alert… it was even BETTER. This movie is an absolute delight and there was not one single minute that I wasn’t entertained and locked in watching it. I adored this movie.

Plot

Per the Hallmark Channel:

After moving to New York to make it on Broadway, Violette Wagner gets a job at Fiore’s, a legendary theater district diner, famous for its singing wait staff, who bide their time there, while awaiting that big break. Luck seems to be on her side when she gets a coveted slot, singing during Fiore’s annual Christmas Eve concert, which is attended by a who’s who of the theatre world. But her big opportunity turns out to be a duet with Alex, who has been less than welcoming, and believes she was only given the job because the owner of Fiore’s is a family friend. They’re stuck with each other, though, since people have been plucked out of that show and put right on Broadway. As they rehearse together, Alex’s cousin, Brad, takes an interest in Violette, and they begin dating but, unbeknownst to her, Alex has been feeding Brad information about her, Cyrano-style, to win her over. However, when Alex begins developing feelings for her as well, a love triangle ensues, and things come to a head when their deception is uncovered, which, in turn, threatens Violette and Alex’s big opportunity. 

From left to right, Paul Essiembre, Charlotte d'Amboise, and John B. Lowe watching the Christmas Eve performances at Fiore's in "A Carol for Two" movie.
Photo Courtesy of HallmarkChannel.com

Actors

Alex

Jordan Litz plays Alex. I had never seen him in any of the Hallmark movies before but I sure hope we do again. I thought he was excellent, and a wonderful talent. And this guy is ALSO on Broadway! He’s played Fiyero in “Wicked” for a over a year now!

Violette

Ginna Claire Mason could sing the phone book and it would be wonderful. She’s fantastic in this movie. She’s gorgeous and has a beautiful voice. I always know it’s going to be amazing when she’s in one of these movies. Oh – and she’s kind of a big deal – she was also GLENDA in “Wicked” on Broadway for several years. Yeah… so… she’s pretty damn good.

Hazel

The character of Hazel stole the show for me. Charlotte d’Amboise was FANTASTIC and was a joy to watch on screen. Can I please learn how to be just like Hazel in my day-to-day life? Charlotte d/Amboise is a literal Broadway star in real life.

The Bottom Line

Ginna Claire Mason and Jordan Litz were fantastic together. I loved this movie. I loved the witty banter. All the performances. Fiore’s. All the Christmas feels. I seriously loved this from beginning to end and so far this is my favorite movie of the Christmas season. Run, don’t walk, and watch this movie immediately. I can’t wait to hear what you think!

From left to right, Jordan Litz, Diana Botelho-Urbanski, Ginna Claire Mason, and Gino Anania posing in front of a Christmas tree on set of "A Carol for Two" movie
Photo Courtesy of HallmarkChannel.com

2024 Christmas Movie Reviews

Are you loving these movie reviews? Try some more!

Movie Must Haves

This post contains affiliate links. If you purchase something from those links, I may make a small commission. See our full Disclosure and Disclaimer Policy here.

I LOVED Ginna Claire Mason’s jacket in several scenes!

No products found.


I also loved her fair isle sweater!

No products found.


I also loved her green blazier in the last scenes of the movie!

No products found.


This is pretty darn close to Violette’s fancy black and gold gown she wears for Christmas Eve!

No products found.


And finally, this is super similar to Rae’s dress where she sings her last song at Fiore’s

No products found.

Location, Location, Location

The movie is set in New York City but was actually filmed in Winnipeg, Manitoba. Lots of the downtown Historic Exchange District works well for looking like New York City when filming.

Fun Fact

This is Ginna Claire Mason’s third Hallmark Christmas movie. Her first was the “Radio City Music Spectacular,” which was the BIG movie of 2022 with the Rockettes and Ginna Claire Mason was a performer. Then last year she was in “A Heidleberg Holiday” and she was wonderful, but it didn’t have anything to do with performing. And then this year she’s an aspiring Broadway star in this movie. I can’t wait to see what they do next!

Stephanie Sy singing her Christmas song on stage at Fiore's in "A Carol for Two" movie
Photo Courtesy of HallmarkChannel.com
Alex and Violette are shopping for items to go into the holiday baskets during a scene from "A Carol for Two" movie
Photo Courtesy of HallmarkChannel.com

Wrap-Up – “A Carol for Two”

This movie was a damn delight and I enjoyed every second of it. The cast of “B” characters was fantastic, and I loved all the performances. It’s a favorite of the year for sure, if not THE favorite of the year. Right now it’s #1 on my list. I can’t wait to hear what you all think of this movie! Let me know! ANd until then, happy watching and Happy Hallmarking!

Personal Disclaimer

These movie reviews and any articles found on this site are my own and my own opinions. I am in no way affiliated or employed by The Hallmark Corporation, Crown Media, Hallmark Media, or any Hallmark or Hallmark-themed podcasts. These opinions are my own and have no professional expertise involved. Any statements are simply my opinions.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *