Toast to Italy Movie Review

Hey Happy Hallmarkers! Pack your bags, pour yourself a glass of wine, and get ready for a little Italian romance because today we’re talking Toast to Italy movie review! Starring Torrey DeVitto and Will Kemp, this sweet Summer Nights movie gave us beautiful scenery, plenty of charm, and a love story that had me smiling all the way through.

Torrey DeVitto and Will Kemp smile on set of "Toast to Italy" Hallmark movie
Photo courtesy of HallmarkChannel.com

Summer Nights is officially back for a few weeks, Happy Hallmarkers! After spending July surrounded by Christmas trees, mistletoe, and plenty of fake snow for Christmas in July, we’re trading all that holiday magic for sunshine, gorgeous destinations, and summer romance. And Toast to Italy was a pretty fantastic way to kick things back off!

It premiered Saturday, August 1, 2026, and Toast to Italy stars Torrey DeVitto and Will Kemp — two Hallmark favorites I am always happy to see on my screen. Send those two to Italy, add a little wine and romance, and you already have a recipe for a movie I’m probably going to enjoy. And enjoy it I did!

Jenny, Lara and the bride talk at the wedding during a scene from "Toast to Italy" Hallmark movie
Photo courtesy of HallmarkChannel.com

My Review

I thought Toast to Italy was absolutely adorable!

This was exactly the kind of movie I want from Hallmark’s Summer Nights lineup. It was light, romantic, charming, and just plain fun to watch. And, of course, having Italy as the backdrop certainly didn’t hurt!

There was just something very easy and enjoyable about this movie. I loved the story, I loved the setting, and I really enjoyed watching the relationships develop throughout the movie. It had plenty of those little Hallmark moments that make you smile, and by the time the credits rolled, I was completely happy with this one.

It’s the kind of Hallmark movie that feels like a mini vacation from your couch — and sometimes that’s exactly what I want!

Plot

Per the Hallmark Channel:

Jenny travels to Italy for a special bottle of wine for her sister’s wedding. She meets Arrigo, also looking for the famous “Love Wine” and together their search leads to a love of their own.

Jenny and her sister look at the wedding dress during a scene from "Toast to Italy" Hallmark movie
Photo courtesy of HallmarkChannel.com

Actors

Torrey DeVitto and Will Kemp were wonderful together.

I’m already a fan of both of them individually, so I was excited to see what they would be like paired together — and they did not disappoint!

They had such an easy chemistry that made their relationship fun to watch. Both Torrey and Will have that wonderful ability to bring warmth and personality to their Hallmark characters, and together they made this story feel sweet and believable.

And really, Will Kemp in an Italian setting with that delightful accent? Hallmark really knew what it was doing here.

If you loved these actors, try these movies:

For more Torrey DeVitto, try these movies:

  • Rip In Time
  • ‘ Twas The Night Before Christmas
  • The Christmas Promise
  • Write Before Christmas

If you loved Will Kemp and want more of him, try these movies:

  • The Christmas Waltz (With Lacey Chabert!)
  • The Dancing Detective: A Deadly Tango
  • A Not So Royal Christmas
  • My Sweet Austrian Holiday
  • Paging Mr. Darcy
  • Love, Romance & Chocolate (also with Lacey Chabert!)
  • Royal Matchmaker
  • Jolly Good Christmas

The Magic Moment

My Magic Moment actually wasn’t about our main couple!

I loved the moment when Jenny and Arrigo gave the wine back to Marcello so that he could give it to Maria and hopefully have another chance at his own love story.

That was such a sweet moment because it wasn’t about winning or keeping something for themselves. Instead, it became about helping two other people find their way back to each other.

Those are the kinds of little moments that give a Hallmark movie its heart, and this one definitely got me.

The Happy Heart Rating

Toast to Italy earns 4 Happy Hearts from me! 💗💗💗💗

I loved this movie. It was charming, romantic, beautifully set, and just an all-around enjoyable watch. Torrey DeVitto and Will Kemp were fantastic together, and the story had exactly the kind of sweetness I want from a Summer Nights movie (Or Happy 25th Birthday Hallmark Channel Movie!).

Four very happy hearts indeed!

The Bottom Line

The bottom line on Toast to Italy?

I loved it!

This was such a fun way to settle back into Summer Nights after our month-long Christmas in July celebration. It gave me romance, gorgeous scenery, characters I enjoyed spending time with, and a story that kept me happily watching from beginning to end.

If you’re looking for a sweet Hallmark escape with a little Italian flair, Toast to Italy is definitely worth adding to your watch list. And now I can’t wait to hear what YOU thought! Did you love Toast to Italy as much as I did? How many Happy Hearts would you give it?

Location, Location, Location

“Toast to Italy” was filmed on location in Orvieto, just outside Rome in Italy. It looks beautiful. Italy was already on my travel bucket list, and this just added to it!

Fun Fact

Will Kemp is actually a classically trained dancer, so all his movies are his very own!

JEnny and Arrigo talk in the church during a scene from "Toast to Italy" Hallmark movie
Photo courtesy of HallmarkChannel.com

Wrap-Up – “Toast to Italy” Movie Review

Toast to Italy gets an enthusiastic thumbs-up from The Happy Hallmarker! This is absolutely one I would watch again. Torrey DeVitto and Will Kemp made a wonderful pairing, the Italian setting gave the movie that extra bit of Summer Nights magic, and the whole thing was simply a joy to watch. After a month filled with Christmas movies, Toast to Italy was a lovely reminder that Hallmark’s summertime romances can bring plenty of magic of their own.

I can’t wait to hear what you thought! Do you love it? Happy Watching, and as always, Happy Hallmarking!

Want to remember this post? Save it to your favorite Pinterest board!

Toast to Italy movie poster on a Pinterest graphic with a 4 happy heart movie rating

Personal Disclaimer

This blog is not affiliated with Hallmark Enterprises, Hallmark Channel, or the Deck The Hallmark podcast in any way. Any opinions and observations are mine alone.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *